Are Amazon Reviews Bogus?

amazon reviews

Lively and interesting conversation lately on regarding all of those delicious stars trailing the best selling books.

Neil (of “Shut Up and Read”) began it all in December 2013 as he ranted, “Are all Amazon reviews bogus???.. Several evaluations are so clearly fake, shills, they have to feel the audience are stupid… ”

Again in January, having read through the articles from a Amazon listing optimization service and feeling pretty strongly about it myself considering the level to which I would worked to obtain some stars in many, noted I spot read reviews; often a few ranked five, but additionally depended on the lesser ranked for some great insight into the eBook. I felt the book descriptions do not constantly accurately describe the title and the eBook could be deceiving.


I value detailed and honest ratings for all the manuscripts I have posted for the grandfather of mine and similarly attempt being quite truthful in the reviews of mine of the books I have read–and I have read through rather several this year; some good–some not. Within view of the time it requires to produce a good comment on the books I completely enjoy, I may rate but won’t usually invest enough time to discuss one I did not care for. I think that many do the exact same, though in reading through user reviews left by others, typically look for a consensus of identical 2 or maybe 3 stars I gave confirming the judgment of mine of the eBook.


The problem of mine here’s that in case I do not go out of an evaluation for the eBook I did not care for (and that appears to be the norm), the writer is deprived of the issues I perceived. The exact same is true for the books I have published–I did not comprehend the motives behind a two star rating which left me curious about how you can solve an issue I am ignorant exists. Obviously it is difficult to really print all those strong terms for somebody else understanding the blood, sweat, along with tears which constitute a manuscript. As Ken from Goodreads wrote… “I’ll look at negative ratings first & find out if they’ve something legitimate to say. You can typically tell if it is real. Occasionally a terrible comment is going to complain about something that I think about a characteristic and that is makes me wish to read the book. I do not truly trust 5 star reviews any more.”

Leonie added… “I nowadays do not wish to get everything high star reviews, since it will make folks suspicious that all the people of mine are friends… ”

Alana said… “Probably approximately seventy % or even much more of what I come across is self published/Indie writer in this particular point.”

Judy noted… “… leery of self published. A lot of are not properly written or edited. But recently I have read through such terrible material that was usually printed that today I *always* download a sample prior to separating with any money.”*

*Yes, absolutely free samples–such as provided by each Smashwords and Amazon Kindle and many eBook sales outlets.

L.A. posted… “Unlike several reviewers I do not destroy the eBook or maybe base the grading system of mine in case I read grammatical errors. Everybody has them regardless of the number of times an eBook went from the editing process.” (Thank you!)

The argument

Then again is the argument intended for self published authors or books published from the huge box publishing houses? I am regularly directed offers of publications for electronic download touting 130 (or more) five star Amazon reviews. Writers of note pen a brief, glowing recommendation, it is a #1 New York Times bestseller, award recipient, and also has stories of more than 300 five star Goodreads reviews. But wait–didn’t Amazon buy out Goodreads?! Would be these stars, scores, and reviews contrived? How can you buy out that numerous people?

Look at the web now and you’re more likely to hear that a brand new Author Earnings article suggests “that self published publications today represent thirty one % of eBook revenue on Amazon’s Kindle Store”–and self published writers generate nearly forty % of the store’s royalties. Additionally, which publications by the important 5 publishers account for just sixteen % of the titles on Amazon’s bestseller list. Okay–but it is not the brand new York Times bestsellers list.

And so just where can they come from? (Rankings reflect income reported by vendors offering a broad range of common interest titles. The product sales venues for print publications include independent book retailers; national, local and regional chains; on the internet and multimedia entertainment retailers… E-book ranks reflect product sales from top internet vendors of e books in an assortment of popular e reader formats.) So then the issue of mine becomes: Just how much fat is provided, in view of quite heavy deals & promos, by *one* (of these) vendors & can they be truly driving scores with offers that are free?

Perceived value

I do not know–but I do think that the perceived value of publishers will go on to drop when the portion of Indie writers increases. The self publishers are learning to post as the workers and are rapidly claiming the delights of self publishing; not the very least of that are significantly increased royalty fees. Based on everything you come across on the online world, self published electronic books will make up fifty % of eBook sales by 2020.

The issue remains–how will these Indie experts produce stars and do not you require stars to sell books? Friends as well as relatives cannot supply every one of them. Next I suspect we’re to the question of promotion and marketing! For self published authors then, it might perfectly be the question of a truly great social media network–unless you’ve the money… “

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *